News – Shocking impact of family courts on women’s health exposed – University of Manchester

Click here to read full research

A devastating study involving 45 women who accused their partners of domestic abuse has highlighted serious health problems they have suffered as a result, they say, of biased family court proceedings.

While the study is qualitative and self-reported and so not generalisable to the wider population, the women’s experiences now indicate a need for further research.

Led by University of Manchester researchers in partnership with members of SHERA Research Group and The Survivor Family Network, the UKRI funded study of the women and their 77 children will be published in the journal of family trauma, child custody and child development in the coming weeks.

The women told the researchers they attributed psychological conditions including  suicide ideation, memory loss, depression and flash backs on what they were going through in court.

They also said physical symptoms such as Crohn’s Disease , cancer, psoriasis, heart palpitations and miscarriage were either exacerbated by or directly associated with the court proceedings.

One respondent told how her mother had a heart attack in court and another how she lost her father to a heart attack also while proceedings were ongoing.

And a respondent told the research team how an acquaintance of hers had killed herself during court proceedings involving allegations of so-called ’parental alienation’.

The study also found:

  • 43 out of the 45 parents, were given access to the children.
  • One child had no contact after the parent accused of violence had abducted the child.
  • In another case, the child reached an age deemed old enough to make their own choice.
  • 43 out of 45 of the mothers’ ex-partners had some form of contact with the children, even the ones with child sexual abuse convictions.

According to the researchers, 39 of the women accusing their former partners of abuse were counter accused of a spurious  legal argument called parental alienation (PA)

PA was used, argue the team,  as a way to deny the abuse and grant access or even residency of their children to the abusive parents.

The remaining six women who were not accused said they were either threatened with PA or mischaracterised as medically or psychologically abnormal.

PA, a belief system universally rejected by Governments, the World Health Organization and other mainstream organisations, supposedly denotes psychological manipulation of a child to turn against his or her parent.

But research shows false allegations are rare and that it is extremely difficult to make a child make false allegations of child sexual abuse.

Though women who have suffered abuse are already highly vulnerable, lead researcher, Dr Elizabeth Dalgarno says the courts tend to side with the male perpetrators by accepting PA.

The tendency for the courts to side with men, says Dr Dalgarno, can be explained by lack of training for judges and court professionals around coercive control and domestic abuse and many believe, a culture of misogyny and woman and victim-blaming which is prevalent in society.

Verified by MonsterInsights