Today marks a pivotal moment in the fight against harmful practices in the UK, as the Greater Manchester Combined Authority (GMCA) proudly launched its comprehensive report, ‘Honour’-based Abuse, Forced Marriage, and Female Genital Mutilation in Greater Manchester: Scoping and Research Exercise. This significant study, prepared by onEvidence, represents an unprecedented and victim-centred piece of research, poised to have far-reaching implications not only across Greater Manchester but potentially for responses to these crimes across England and Wales.
The report’s launch highlights a clear commitment to radically transform how gender-based violence (GBV) is addressed, prioritising a stronger, more effective response for those at risk. This is an essential step towards ensuring that the human-centred narratives of victims and survivors drive real improvements in support services.
A Collaborative Endeavour for Lasting Change
onEvidence is honoured to have been commissioned for this vital research, a testament to GMCA’s commendable leadership in confronting the complex realities of HBA, FM, and FGM. The project was expertly authored by Professor (Hon) Roxanne Khan and Paul Morris, with Dr Peggy Mulongo serving as Co-investigator and the Greater Manchester Context Lead from onEvidence.
This work was steered by GMCA Commissioners Emma Stonier and Carol Judge-Campbell, and enriched by the invaluable contributions of national consultants including Dr Maryyum Mehmood, Meena Kumari, and Yasmin Khan. Their diverse expertise, spanning academic insights, best practice in service delivery, training needs, and the nuances of faith and religion, proved instrumental.
The report also acknowledges the critical input from a wide array of stakeholders and partners, including emergency services, social and health services, academics, educators, charities, and community groups. Most importantly, the indispensable contributions of the Voluntary, Community, Faith, and Social Enterprise (VCFSE) sector – especially ‘by-and-for’ organisations and those with lived experience – formed the bedrock upon which truly effective services must be built.
Our Approach: Victim-Centred, Rigorous, and Ethical
This scoping and research exercise was initiated following the decommissioning of Project Choice, a previous victim support service, highlighting an urgent need to revisit and refocus the regional approach to these harmful practices. Our primary aim was to inform future GMCA commissioning, ensuring an integrated, region-wide support system for victims.
To achieve this, we adopted a participatory, mixed-methods approach, grounding the research in local context and prioritising the voices of those affected. This involved:
- A rapid review of existing literature, demographic data, and crime statistics.
- Analysis of previously unpublished regional data from Greater Manchester Police (GMP) and Project Choice.
- An online survey with victim service providers across Greater Manchester.
- Two online focus group discussions with 18 local stakeholders from diverse sectors.
- In-depth consultations with national experts.
Our methodology ensured that the research was not just data-driven but also deeply empathetic. A full ethics appraisal was conducted and approved by GMCA, ensuring voluntary participation and anonymity for all involved, upholding the highest standards of research integrity.
Headline Findings: Uncovering Hidden Harms
The report’s findings paint a complex picture of HBA, FM, and FGM in Greater Manchester, revealing essential insights for victims and services:
The Scale of Underreporting: Accurately determining the true prevalence of these harms is a significant challenge due to “fuzzy data” and substantial underreporting. Official statistics, such as those from GMP or the Forced Marriage Unit, represent only a fraction of the actual scale of these hidden crimes. This means many victims remain invisible, underlining the urgent need for proactive identification and support.
Diversity of Victims: While South Asian women and girls are disproportionately affected by HBA and FM, and FGM primarily impacts females from Black African communities, these harmful practices transcend specific demographics. The previously funded Project Choice demonstrated this by supporting clients from 33 different ethnicities, highlighting that men and LGBTQ+ individuals are also victims. A “one-size-fits-all approach is inadequate”; services must be culturally appropriate, accessible, and tailored to individual intersecting vulnerabilities.
Complex Perpetration Dynamics: These abuses are rarely carried out by a single individual. Instead, they typically involve multiple perpetrators, often supported or tacitly approved by family and/or community members. Motivations are rooted in a distorted sense of ‘honour’ and a desire to control behaviour. While male relatives often act as primary abusers, the significant role of female relatives – including mothers and mothers-in-law – in perpetrating and condoning abuse must not be overlooked. This necessitates nuanced interventions that address complex family dynamics.
Critical Gaps in Service Provision: The research identified significant gaps and inconsistencies in support, including inadequate and unsustainable funding, which creates instability and hinders long-term planning for vital VCFSE organisations. There is a lack of 24-hour support, culturally sensitive interpreters, safe accommodation, and dedicated services for male and LGBTQ+ victims.
Guiding Future Priorities and Funding
GMCA has a clear intention to use these findings to guide its priorities, funding, and commissioning decisions, ensuring services truly correspond to the level of need. This report’s recommendations will be leveraged to drive a more integrated and region-wide response to GBV.
The implications extend far beyond Greater Manchester. The report highlights the key role of ‘by-and-for’ organisations, advocating for their recognition as lead delivery partners due to their local knowledge and cultural understanding. On a national level, the findings highlight the need for lobbying the UK Government to mandate and standardise ethnicity recording and improve national data collection. This robust evidence is vital for justifying sustained funding at both local and national levels, and the report’s proposed cross-governmental ring-fenced fund has the potential to reshape funding for specialist services across England and Wales.
A Forward-Looking Vision for Change
The launch of this report is not a conclusion, but a beginning. Greater Manchester is committed to transforming its approach to HBA, FM, and FGM, moving forward with a clear set of recommendations:
- Implement a unified, Greater Manchester-wide strategy: This will establish standardised definitions and consistent data collection mechanisms across all ten boroughs.
- Establish sustainable, long-term funding models: Moving away from short-term grants to provide stable resources for specialist services.
- Ensure comprehensive and specialised training: Mandatory, ongoing training for professionals in all relevant sectors (health, education, social services, policing) to improve understanding and culturally sensitive responses.
- Strengthen multi-agency collaboration: Enhancing communication, information sharing, and establishing clear referral pathways between all relevant agencies.
- Increase community engagement and awareness-raising: Developing culturally sensitive campaigns and educational activities, actively involving community members and leaders to challenge harmful norms and empower individuals.
These recommendations are designed to be Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound, with clear implementation timelines and responsibilities across GMCA and its partners.
Join the Movement for Safety and Equality
This report must act as a call to action for all of us within the GMCA and our partner organisations to unite and drive forward the improvements required to ensure the safety of all victims and survivors of these abhorrent crimes.
Kate Green, Deputy Mayor, Greater Manchester
We invite you to read the full report and join us in this crucial mission. Download the GMCA’s full report here: ‘Honour’-based Abuse, Forced Marriage, and Female Genital Mutilation in Greater Manchester: Scoping and Research Exercise
Please share this report widely within your networks and organisations.
onEvidence is committed to supporting this transformative agenda. As an independent research consultancy with deep expertise in gender-based violence, we are uniquely positioned to assist. We offer independent research, bespoke training, and provide expert safeguarding consultancy to ensure that all professionals and services are equipped to protect and empower victims.
Contact onEvidence today to explore how we can support your organisation in implementing these vital recommendations and contribute to a Greater Manchester, and indeed, a UK, free from these harmful practices
