A report has revealed trust remains a key issue in the policing of violence against women and girls in Black and minoritised communities – and this type of crime is much less likely to result in offenders being charged compared to other offences.
The findings follow two recent major policing reports, namely the Metropolitan Police Casey Review and Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS) final inspection report on Police response to violence against women and girls, which highlighted institutional racism and systematic failures in safeguarding women and girls from violence. The reports called for a radical overhaul of police responses to these crimes.
Less than a quarter (24%) of the 55 studied police case files on domestic violence, rape, and serious sexual assault offences overall resulted in charges being brought against an offender, according to the findings which covered two police forces.
“This low charging rate is highly disproportionate compared to police forces’ performance nationally concerning most other crimes, which achieve much higher charging levels.
“Our findings echo crime outcomes in England and Wales, which show rape offences seldom result in a charge or summons and we need to better understand the many complicated factors influencing this. Home Office data shows that just 1.3% of the recorded rape offences that were assigned an outcome resulted in a charge or summons.”
Lower levels of trust in the police among the racially minoritised were acknowledged by majority of officers surveyed in the report in collaboration with the University of Sheffield.
The officer indicated more training is needed so officers can overcome their prejudices and preconceptions and be more aware when addressing particular groups.
Some respondents noted how decline in trust was not only apparent among members of the public but was also affecting their relationship and joint working with other statutory service.
Respondents also highlighted how erosion of trust in the police was often the outcome of the workings of the criminal justice system more broadly, with the public viewing the police as the face of that system and hence blamed them for broader systemic failures. In many cases, officers pointed to challenges in gathering sufficient evidence to meet the threshold required by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS). The majority of the 54 officers in the focus groups emphasised the inherent difficulties of evidencing violence against women due to its ‘private’ nature and attributed the attrition in the criminal justice system at this stage of the process to the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).
Survivors’ reluctance to support a prosecution was evident across all data sources. On the whole, the decision to prosecute was shaped by the victims’ wishes as well as the police’s assessment of the re-victimisation risk and concerns around safeguarding the victim and any children.
The report, funded by the UKRI Economic and Social Research Council, will be presented to experts in the field and community representatives in Bristol this week.
“Although the number of survey participants was relatively small, the qualitative feedback provides important insights on common themes and issues. One of the many ways in which the police officers were reaching out to their local communities was through awareness-raising and proactive interventions to inform members of the public about what they could expect from their police force. The officers reiterated the key role of proactive policing within communities and identified community engagement as a key factor in rebuilding trust.”
