Consultation Evidence – Mandatory reporting of child sexual abuse: call for evidence – Home Office

Seeking views on how a legal duty to report child sexual abuse would affect children, organisations, workplaces and volunteers the government had launched a public consultation. Further to this call for evidence, the government has began a public consultation to set out proposals for delivering a mandatory reporting duty and to test opinion on a small number of undecided policy questions. A single government response addressing both of these consultation exercises will be published as soon as possible.

About this call for evidence
Investigations undertaken by the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse documented unacceptable cases of organisations and institutions failing to protect those in their care from child sexual abuse (Lambeth Council, Residential Schools, Child Sexual Exploitation in Organised Networks, and more). This must not be allowed to happen again.

The Government remains firmly committed to tackling all forms of child sexual abuse, putting the needs of children first. Wherever possible, action should be taken to prevent child sexual abuse through safer recruitment practices, robust policies and procedures, and creating a system-wide safeguarding culture. Where abuse does occur, it is critical that frontline professionals and volunteers are equipped with the right training and resources to identify and respond to child sexual abuse, and improve how they work with child victims.

In its final report, the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse recommended that Government introduce a mandatory reporting duty for cases of child sexual abuse:

Recommendation 13: Mandatory reporting
The Inquiry recommends that the UK government and Welsh Government introduce legislation which places certain individuals – ‘mandated reporters’ – under a statutory duty to report child sexual abuse where they:

receive a disclosure of child sexual abuse from a child or perpetrator; or witness a child being sexually abused; or observe recognised indicators of child sexual abuse. The following persons should be designated ‘mandated reporters’:

Any person working in regulated activity in relation to children (under the Safeguarding and Vulnerable Groups Act 2006, as amended);

Any person working in a position of trust (as defined by the Sexual Offences Act 2003, as amended); and police officers.

For the purposes of mandatory reporting, ‘child sexual abuse’ should be interpreted as any act that would be an offence under the Sexual Offences Act 2003 where the alleged victim is a child under the age of 18.

Where the child is aged between 13 and under 16 years old, a report need not be made where the mandated reporter reasonably believes that: the relationship between the parties is consensual and not intimidatory, exploitative or coercive; and the child has not been harmed and is not at risk of being harmed; and there is no material difference in capacity or maturity between the parties engaged in the sexual activity concerned, and there is a difference in age of no more than three years.

These exceptions should not, however, apply where the alleged perpetrator is in a position of trust within the meaning of the 2003 Act. Where the child is under the age of 13, a report must always be made. Reports should be made to either local authority children’s social care or the police as soon as is practicable. It should be a criminal offence for mandated reporters to fail to report child sexual abuse where they: are in receipt of a disclosure of child sexual abuse from a child or perpetrator; or witness a child being sexually abused.

In light of this recommendation, we are launching this call for evidence which seeks views on how implementing a duty to report child sexual abuse is likely to impact children, organisations, and affected workforces and volunteers; and how different aspects could be implemented.

The call for evidence is particularly aimed at those working with children and young people in regulated activity or positions of trust (including in the charity, voluntary and community sectors), those involved in law enforcement and, more generally, individuals and groups working with children and supporting those affected by child sexual abuse. We recognise that these sectors currently operate under different requirements in terms of their work with children and young people. We want to collect responses from as broad a spectrum as possible so that we can accurately assess how best to implement mandatory reporting, including what support and resources may be needed, and what the potential implications might be. However, the above list is not meant to be exhaustive or exclusive, and responses are welcomed from anyone with an interest in or views on the subject covered by this paper.

The geographical scope of the call for evidence is England. Though many elements of the recommendation are devolved to Wales, crime, policing and criminal justice are not. The Home Office will work closely with the Welsh Government to ensure that the results of this call for evidence are meaningful in a Welsh context.

This call for evidence relates to a sensitive and distressing topic. It is not in itself designed to capture disclosures of, or concerns around, incidents of child sexual abuse. Such concerns should be reported directly to the police or your local children’s services. You can also get advice or report your concerns anonymously to the NSPCC by phoning its free helpline on 0808 800 5000; or via email.

Under the Home Office’s established protocols, we will refer any disclosures of child sexual abuse to the police for their consideration. Further information about how your response and any personal data will be handled can be found below (‘Confidentiality’).

Implementing a statutory duty to report child sexual abuse
IICSA Recommendation

Across seven years of investigation, the Inquiry heard the important testimonies and lived experience of over 7,300 victims and survivors as well as considering the Government’s 2016 consultation on mandatory reporting of abuse and neglect. The evidence it considered, which ranged from historical to contemporary accounts, demonstrated that when abuse was disclosed individuals and institutions often thought children were lying.

In some cases, reputational concerns were prioritised over the safety of children, despite allegations or actual knowledge of sexually abusive behaviour. In others, a culture of indifference led to a succession of missed opportunities to intervene in the life of a vulnerable child. Appallingly, some victims testified to being mocked and bullied by safeguarding professionals when they directly disclosed details about the sexual abuse they suffered. Many more set out that inadequate and negative responses to their disclosures meant they never wanted to talk about their experiences again.

After considering the issue across several of its investigations, the Inquiry recommended in its final report to Government that a mandatory reporting regime should be established in respect of child sexual abuse cases. The duty proposed by the Inquiry would apply where a victim or an abuser discloses that a child is being sexually abused, as well as in cases where child sexual abuse is witnessed or signs are observed that indicate that a child has been sexually abused. It would be a criminal offence to fail to report a disclosure or witnessed incident of child sexual abuse.

The scope of the Inquiry’s recommendation is broad, applying to anyone working in regulated activity with children, persons in positions of trust and police officers. The Inquiry also sets out that specific ‘whistleblowing’ protections should be in place for individuals when reports are made in good faith.

Government position
Child sexual abuse causes deep and enduring damage that can last for a lifetime. Those who work with children or hold positions of trust are in a unique position to help prevent abuse and identify when a child is suffering abuse. We know that keeping children safe from harm would not be possible without the combined efforts of professionals and volunteers across all sectors of society, and that the vast majority undertake this challenging work with a dedication that can have a transformative impact on the lives of vulnerable children and young people. We are continuing to invest in a range of measures to equip those working with children with the confidence and capability they need to tackle what is a complex and continually evolving threat.

The Government already sets clear expectations through statutory guidance (Working Together to Safeguard Children, Keeping children safe in education, Section 3 of the Statutory framework for the early years foundation stage) and non-statutory guidance (Keeping Children Safe in Out of School Settings) that practitioners working with children should make an immediate referral to the relevant local authority children’s social care if they believe that a child has suffered harm (or is likely to do so). There is also existing provision in law to pursue the concealment of an arrestable offence.

Despite the existing referral framework and continuing best efforts, we know that abuse continues to go unreported. As recently as April 2023, the Child Safeguarding Practice Review Panel published a two-part national review into safeguarding children with disabilities in residential settings; which sets out how and why a significant number of children with complex needs came to suffer serious abuse and neglect while living in three privately provided residential settings.

We know from the evidence considered by the Inquiry that victims of child sexual abuse were repeatedly failed by those who should have protected them, including safeguarding professionals who failed in their duties and allowed abuse to continue. The reasons put forward for this varied from a desire to protect an individual or institution from reputational damage, feeling unable to challenge the judgement of senior colleagues, and confusing or subjective procedures for assessing and handling reports of child sexual abuse. It is clear that more work is needed to ensure that the expectations on those working with children are unambiguous; and that they must be provided with the appropriate support to act.

We have given close consideration to the views and experiences of thousands of adult victims and survivors surveyed by the Inquiry. The vast majority of those respondents (88.6%) said that they would like to see mandatory reporting of child sexual abuse introduced. Some suggested the existence of a mandatory reporting duty at the time of their abuse could have led to action being taken, or the perpetrator being brought to justice.

If delivered effectively, a mandatory reporting duty provides an important mechanism for accountability where young people have been failed by those responsible for their care, creates a clearly understood process for reporters to take action (with robust personal and professional protections), and most importantly, ensures that more victims can be identified and safeguarded.

We agree with the Inquiry that the issue of organisations and individuals in positions of responsibility and trust failing to report must now be acted on. We have committed to working across Government to consult on a measured and phased approach, which is sensitive to wider impact and burdens, and considers whether action is needed at the individual or organisational level, or both.

We are conscious that such a duty could have a significant impact on a wide range of sectors – some of which are already under significant pressure, are already in the process of reform, or are less closely regulated but still involve a significant amount of contact with children. In order to implement mandatory reporting effectively, we want this call for evidence to gather a wide range of information on its potential impact. This will allow us to take all relevant considerations into account when developing specific proposals for testing.

Verified by MonsterInsights